Utica First Insurance Company — homeowners Insurance Complaints
Analysis of 51 homeowners insurance complaints filed against Utica First Insurance Company, based on public NAIC and state DOI data.
Key Statistics
- homeowners Complaints: 51
- Total Complaints (All Types): 64
- homeowners Share: 79.7%
- AI Risk Score: 37/100
homeowners Complaint Issues
| Issue Type | Complaints | % of Total |
|---|---|---|
| Nonrenewal | Underwriting | Company Position Substantiated | 14 | 27.5% |
| Claim denial | 13 | 25.5% |
| Unfair settlement | 10 | 19.6% |
| Delayed payment | 5 | 9.8% |
| Premium or billing dispute | 3 | 5.9% |
| Nonrenewal | Underwriting | 2 | 3.9% |
| Adjuster Handling | Claim Handling | Company Position Substantiated | 2 | 3.9% |
| Refusal to Insure | Underwriting | 1 | 2.0% |
| Adjuster Handling | Claim Handling | Company Position Overturned | 1 | 2.0% |
homeowners Complaints by State
| State | Complaints |
|---|---|
| Connecticut | 51 |
Recent homeowners Complaints Against Utica First Insurance Company
- homeowners Complaint #CT-7085050-f620b359 — Connecticut (2026-04-27)
- homeowners Complaint #CT-7084743-1f22c41f — Connecticut (2026-04-16)
- homeowners Complaint #CT-7084577-3efaf88e — Connecticut (2026-04-13)
- homeowners Complaint #CT-7079945-50995483 — Connecticut (2025-11-12)
- homeowners Complaint #CT-7079366-510d5c3a — Connecticut (2025-10-27)
- homeowners Complaint #CT-7079057-3f315e8b — Connecticut (2025-10-15)
- homeowners Complaint #CT-7078013-c18a697e — Connecticut (2025-09-05)
- homeowners Complaint #CT-7077709-92dbfc93 — Connecticut (2025-08-26)
- homeowners Complaint #CT-7077214-9f0b54d7 — Connecticut (2025-08-07)
- homeowners Complaint #CT-7076376-d565d054 — Connecticut (2025-07-08)
Frequently Asked Questions
How many homeowners complaints does Utica First Insurance Company have?
Utica First Insurance Company has 51 homeowners insurance complaints on file, according to NAIC and state DOI data.
What are the most common homeowners complaint issues with Utica First Insurance Company?
The most common homeowners complaint issues for Utica First Insurance Company are: Nonrenewal | Underwriting | Company Position Substantiated (14), Claim denial (13), Unfair settlement (10), Delayed payment (5), Premium or billing dispute (3).
Which states have the most homeowners complaints against Utica First Insurance Company?
The states with the most homeowners complaints against Utica First Insurance Company are: Connecticut (51).
homeowners Complaints by State
- homeowners Complaints in California
- homeowners Complaints in Texas
- homeowners Complaints in New York
- homeowners Complaints in Florida
- homeowners Complaints in Illinois
- homeowners Complaints in Pennsylvania
- homeowners Complaints in Ohio
- homeowners Complaints in Georgia
- homeowners Complaints in North Carolina
- homeowners Complaints in New Jersey
Utica First Insurance Company Complaints by State
- Utica First Insurance Company Complaints in California
- Utica First Insurance Company Complaints in Texas
- Utica First Insurance Company Complaints in New York
- Utica First Insurance Company Complaints in Florida
- Utica First Insurance Company Complaints in Illinois
- Utica First Insurance Company Complaints in Pennsylvania
- Utica First Insurance Company Complaints in Ohio
- Utica First Insurance Company Complaints in Georgia
- Utica First Insurance Company Complaints in North Carolina
- Utica First Insurance Company Complaints in New Jersey