UTICA MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY — auto Complaints in Connecticut

Detailed analysis of 28 auto insurance complaints filed against UTICA MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY by consumers in Connecticut, based on public NAIC and state DOI data.

Key Statistics

auto Complaints in Connecticut: 28
Total auto Complaints (All States): 28
Connecticut Share: 100.0%
NAIC Complaint Ratio: 0.13
AI Risk Score: 26/100

Analysis: UTICA MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY auto in Connecticut

UTICA MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY has accumulated 28 auto insurance complaints from consumers in Connecticut. Across all states, UTICA MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY has 28 total auto complaints, making Connecticut responsible for 100.0% of the volume.

The most frequent complaint sub-type is Claim denial with 7 complaints. Other common issues include Delayed payment (5), Premium or billing dispute (4), Unfair settlement (3).

The most active year was 2026 with 3 complaints filed.

Consumers in Connecticut who have auto disputes with UTICA MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY can file a complaint with the Connecticut Department of Insurance.

auto Complaint Issues in Connecticut

Issue Type	Complaints	%
Claim denial	7	25.0%
Delayed payment	5	17.9%
Premium or billing dispute	4	14.3%
Unfair settlement	3	10.7%
Actual Cash Value Dispute \| Claim Handling	1	3.6%
Nonrenewal \| Underwriting \| Company Position Substantiated	1	3.6%
Subrogation \| Claim Handling	1	3.6%
Claim Procedure \| Claim Handling \| Company Position Substantiated	1	3.6%
Policy cancellation	1	3.6%
Excessive Charges \| Underwriting \| Company Position Substantiated	1	3.6%
CLUE Reports \| Underwriting \| Company Position Substantiated	1	3.6%
Adjuster Handling \| Claim Handling	1	3.6%
Misleading sales	1	3.6%

Complaints by Year

2026: 3 complaints
2025: 3 complaints
2024: 7 complaints
2023: 6 complaints
2022: 8 complaints
2021: 1 complaints

Recent auto Complaints Against UTICA MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY in Connecticut

auto Complaint #CT-7084678-df4105e9 (2026-04-15) — Actual Cash Value Dispute | Claim Handling
auto Complaint #CT-7082320-2239984f (2026-02-02) — Claim denial
auto Complaint #CT-7081463-a7b2ecf2 (2026-01-07) — Claim denial
auto Complaint #CT-7080173-9301ddfd (2025-11-18) — Claim denial
auto Complaint #CT-7078838-2a385dd2 (2025-10-06) — Nonrenewal | Underwriting | Company Position Substantiated
auto Complaint #CT-7071749-bccc2b6a (2025-01-21) — Subrogation | Claim Handling
auto Complaint #CT-7070826-b295904e (2024-12-13) — Premium or billing dispute
auto Complaint #CT-7070191-e5597297 (2024-11-21) — Premium or billing dispute
auto Complaint #CT-7069538-f725eded (2024-11-04) — Premium or billing dispute
auto Complaint #CT-7069110-016b58b8 (2024-10-21) — Claim Procedure | Claim Handling | Company Position Substantiated

Frequently Asked Questions

How many auto complaints does UTICA MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY have in Connecticut?

UTICA MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY has 28 auto insurance complaints on file from consumers in Connecticut, according to NAIC and state DOI data.

What are the most common auto complaint issues with UTICA MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY in Connecticut?

The most common issues are: Claim denial (7), Delayed payment (5), Premium or billing dispute (4), Unfair settlement (3), Actual Cash Value Dispute | Claim Handling (1).

How does UTICA MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY's auto record in Connecticut compare to other states?

UTICA MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY has 28 auto complaints in Connecticut out of 28 total auto complaints nationwide. That is 100.0% of their auto volume.

Where can I file a auto complaint against UTICA MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY in Connecticut?

You can file a complaint with the Connecticut Department of Insurance. The NAIC Consumer Information Source at https://content.naic.org/cis_consumer.htm also accepts complaints.