Utica First Insurance Company — homeowners Complaints in Connecticut

Detailed analysis of 51 homeowners insurance complaints filed against Utica First Insurance Company by consumers in Connecticut, based on public NAIC and state DOI data.

Key Statistics

homeowners Complaints in Connecticut: 51
Total homeowners Complaints (All States): 51
Connecticut Share: 100.0%
AI Risk Score: 37/100

Analysis: Utica First Insurance Company homeowners in Connecticut

Utica First Insurance Company has accumulated 51 homeowners insurance complaints from consumers in Connecticut. Across all states, Utica First Insurance Company has 51 total homeowners complaints, making Connecticut responsible for 100.0% of the volume.

The most frequent complaint sub-type is Nonrenewal | Underwriting | Company Position Substantiated with 14 complaints. Other common issues include Claim denial (13), Unfair settlement (10), Delayed payment (5).

The most active year was 2026 with 3 complaints filed.

Consumers in Connecticut who have homeowners disputes with Utica First Insurance Company can file a complaint with the Connecticut Department of Insurance.

homeowners Complaint Issues in Connecticut

Issue Type	Complaints	%
Nonrenewal \| Underwriting \| Company Position Substantiated	14	27.5%
Claim denial	13	25.5%
Unfair settlement	10	19.6%
Delayed payment	5	9.8%
Premium or billing dispute	3	5.9%
Nonrenewal \| Underwriting	2	3.9%
Adjuster Handling \| Claim Handling \| Company Position Substantiated	2	3.9%
Refusal to Insure \| Underwriting	1	2.0%
Adjuster Handling \| Claim Handling \| Company Position Overturned	1	2.0%

Complaints by Year

2026: 3 complaints
2025: 13 complaints
2024: 12 complaints
2023: 15 complaints
2022: 7 complaints
2021: 1 complaints

Recent homeowners Complaints Against Utica First Insurance Company in Connecticut

homeowners Complaint #CT-7085050-f620b359 (2026-04-27) — Premium or billing dispute
homeowners Complaint #CT-7084743-1f22c41f (2026-04-16) — Claim denial
homeowners Complaint #CT-7084577-3efaf88e (2026-04-13) — Unfair settlement
homeowners Complaint #CT-7079945-50995483 (2025-11-12) — Claim denial
homeowners Complaint #CT-7079366-510d5c3a (2025-10-27) — Unfair settlement
homeowners Complaint #CT-7079057-3f315e8b (2025-10-15) — Claim denial
homeowners Complaint #CT-7078013-c18a697e (2025-09-05) — Nonrenewal | Underwriting | Company Position Substantiated
homeowners Complaint #CT-7077709-92dbfc93 (2025-08-26) — Delayed payment
homeowners Complaint #CT-7077214-9f0b54d7 (2025-08-07) — Premium or billing dispute
homeowners Complaint #CT-7076376-d565d054 (2025-07-08) — Claim denial

Frequently Asked Questions

How many homeowners complaints does Utica First Insurance Company have in Connecticut?

Utica First Insurance Company has 51 homeowners insurance complaints on file from consumers in Connecticut, according to NAIC and state DOI data.

What are the most common homeowners complaint issues with Utica First Insurance Company in Connecticut?

The most common issues are: Nonrenewal | Underwriting | Company Position Substantiated (14), Claim denial (13), Unfair settlement (10), Delayed payment (5), Premium or billing dispute (3).

How does Utica First Insurance Company's homeowners record in Connecticut compare to other states?

Utica First Insurance Company has 51 homeowners complaints in Connecticut out of 51 total homeowners complaints nationwide. That is 100.0% of their homeowners volume.

Where can I file a homeowners complaint against Utica First Insurance Company in Connecticut?

You can file a complaint with the Connecticut Department of Insurance. The NAIC Consumer Information Source at https://content.naic.org/cis_consumer.htm also accepts complaints.